Shingle or Metal Roofing

Shingle or Metal Roof: What’s the best option for you?

Trying to decide between Shingle or Metal Roof? 

A complete roof replacement can be a costly investment for any homeowner, but luckily, one you won't have to make so often if you hire a reliable residential roofing contractor for the job

Likewise, the roofing materials you choose can also make a huge difference. Each material presents advantages and disadvantages from an upfront investment point of view as well as from a perspective on durability and resistance to the elements. 

This article will focus on shingles and metal, two of the most popular roof material options among homeowners in Florida and Texas in 2022, such as shingles and metal roofing.

Shingle Roofs

Shingle roofs are a common sight on American homes, and for a good reason. They're versatile, stylish, and last for decades with the proper care. There are various kinds of shingles, including wood shingles. Yet, asphalt shingles are, by far, the most common to find and the ones that offer more styles to choose from. In this department, GAF Timberline HDZ shingles are undoubtedly the best value in the market nowadays.

The downside of Shingle Roofs

Shingle roofs have a few downsides: they don't provide as much insulation as other types of roofing and don't last as long in extreme weather conditions (exceptionally high winds). That said, shingle roofs aren't the ideal choice for houses in hurricane-prone areas. If you're in an area prone to extreme weather like Florida, it's worth looking into metal roofs.

Are you looking for a reliable GAF Master Elite Roofer in your area?

Contact Superior One Roofing today! We will offer high quality shingle roof replacement along with the best roofing warranties in America to protect your roof replacement investment. 

Better Business Bureau
master elite roofer

Licensed Roofing Company


What is a metal roof?

Metal roofs are made up of many different types of metal, such as galvalume and aluminum. Among the main advantages of metal roofing systems are that they are highly resistants, fireproof, and coated with special chemicals that make them resistant to termites and other pests. Nevertheless, the most remarkable advantage of metal roofs is that they last for many years and don't require much maintenance. 

Metal vs. Shingles - Cost Comparison

Although shingle and metal roofs are both excellent choices, let's compare the two types of roofing to see which one is more cost-effective.

Metal roofs are becoming more popular among homeowners because of their durability, longevity, and low maintenance costs. However, many people still prefer to go with shingles because they still represent a more affordable option. And although it's true, it's safe to say that metal roofs give you the best value in the long run, as the lifespan of a metal roof is much longer than a shingle roof.

The average lifespan of a shingle roof is anywhere between 10 to 15 years, whereas a metal roof can last 30 years or more. On the other hand, metal roofs can withstand extreme weather events like no other material, which means you won't have to worry too much about storm damage like you would do with a shingle roof, for example.

Lastly, maintaining a metal roof is relatively easy. All you have to do is make sure no debris accumulates on the top of your roof, which can cause leaks. Conversely, shingles need more gradual maintenance and repair, depending on the wear and tear they receive due to the climate in your area. Repainting the underside of the shingles is also a requirement every few years.

superior one roofing logo

Are you looking for a licensed metal roofing contractor?

Contact the team at Superior One Roofing today for a free estimate for metal roof installation cost!

+2000 projects under our belt, +100 customer reviews, and a 4.8 star rating endorse our outstanding expertise and quality.
metal roofing contractor projects

Metal vs. Shingles - Aesthetics

Aesthetics is one of the most apparent differences between metal and shingle roofs. Some people can often perceive metal as too synthetic, and that's a fair point. Shingles offer a more natural look than metal as they are made from organic materials. Nevertheless, it's worth mentioning that metal roofing systems have evolved, and now they come in various colors and styles that can even emulate the look of having traditional shingles.

Metal vs. Shingles - Heat Retention

Since metal is a better insulator than shingles, a metal roof can reduce heat loss through the roof by as much as 50 percent — a metal roof could lower your heating bills in the winter and increase them in the summer compared with a shingle roof.

How long will it take to install a metal Metal vs. Shingle roof? 

The average shingle installation takes roughly two days, while metal roofs may almost certainly take longer depending on the roof size. However, it's worth consulting with your roofing contractor as there are a lot of factors to consider in a roof installation project.

Get a free quote for
roof installation today! Contact us for a free roof inspection to get an accurate estimation of how much your new shingle or metal roof will cost and how long it will take to get it done!

Ready to Request a Free Roof Replacement Quote?

Superior One Roofing is a highly Rated Roofing Company with over 40 years in business and thousands of roof replacement projects completed under our belt.

Work with a Reputable Florida Roofing Company

4.9 Rating on Google

Main Cities We Service